
Which Shall Live— Men or Animals?
WHICH SHALL LIVE—MEN OR ANIMALS?
When a nation faces a foreign army, its citizens rally, draft troops, and pour resources into a single, visible battle. The author asks us to consider a different, far more relentless foe—disease—whose armies of microbes wage war on us constantly, yet rarely stir the same collective response. By drawing this stark contrast, the essay invites listeners to rethink how we value the unseen battles that shape public health.
The narrative then turns to the historic scourge of bubonic plague, recounting how early 20th‑century scientists used experiments on rats, fleas, and monkeys to uncover the disease’s true vector. Those findings sparked practical measures—trapping rodents, eliminating flea habitats, and safeguarding ports—that transformed a terrifying epidemic into a manageable threat. Through this compelling account, the piece makes a powerful case for the role of animal research in protecting humanity from invisible enemies.
Language
en
Duration
~18 minutes (17K characters)
Publisher of text edition
Project Gutenberg
Original publisher
United States: American Medical Association, 1923.
Credits
Donald Cummings and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at https://www.pgdp.net (This file was produced from images generously made available by The Internet Archive/American Libraries.)
Release date
2021-07-31
Rights
Public domain in the USA.
Subjects

1868–1925
A lively early conservation writer, he helped draw public attention to endangered birds and the American bison. His books blend close observation, storytelling, and a clear affection for wild creatures.
View all books
by Order of the Eastern Star. General Grand Chapter

by John Henry Newman

by Stendhal

by Henry Adams

by Stephen Charnock

by Brillat-Savarin

by Honoré de Balzac

by A. T. (Andrew Taylor) Still