Some Remarks on the Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, Written by Mr. William Shakespeare (1736)

An anonymous scholar from the eighteenth century offers a lively, accessible commentary on Shakespeare’s most famous Danish prince. Written in a clear, Addison‑inspired voice, the essay navigates the play’s key scenes, speeches, and characters with a balance of wit and rigor. It also unpacks the heated textual debates of its day, weighing the merits of rival editions and the critics who shaped them.

The author’s strong preference for Theobald’s notes over Pope’s celebrated edition reveals the polemical atmosphere surrounding Hamlet’s publication history. By tracing how ideas about the tragedy evolved, the essay anticipates later critical approaches that would become standard in Shakespeare studies. Its thoughtful observations have resonated through generations of scholars, influencing figures from Johnson to modern literary historians.

Listening to this work provides a glimpse into the early formation of historical criticism, while still offering fresh insights for today’s readers. Engaging passages invite reflection on the play’s enduring questions, making the essay a rewarding companion for anyone curious about the foundations of Shakespearean analysis.