
E-text prepared by Suzanne Shell and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team (http://www.pgdp.net) from page images generously made available by Internet Archive/American Libraries (http://www.archive.org/details/americana)
BY JOHN MACY - Author of "The Spirit of American Literature," etc.
BONI and LIVERIGHT Publishers New York - Copyright, 1922, by Boni and Liveright, Inc. - Printed in the United States of America.
This treatise treats literary criticism as a lively sport, comparing the critic’s craft to a game of whist or a match of tennis. It argues that the same impulses—intellect, skill, and the desire to entertain an audience—drive both creators and their commentators. By weaving witty observations with thoughtful examples from figures like Lamb, Arnold, and Thackeray, the author shows how criticism can be as graceful, provocative, and original as any poem or novel. The opening pages set the tone for a conversation that celebrates the personal, almost confessional, nature of a critic’s voice.
Readers are invited to explore a panorama of essays that examine how critics reveal as much about themselves as the works they dissect. The book balances historical insight with a modern sensibility, making the art of evaluation feel both accessible and intellectually rewarding. It promises a thoughtful, often humorous, journey through the tangled relationship between writer, reader, and the ever‑evolving game of critique.
Language
en
Duration
~5 hours (328K characters)
Release date
2012-01-03
Rights
Public domain in the USA.

1877–1932
Best remembered for helping shape the early books of Helen Keller, this Harvard-educated editor and critic brought a lively, opinionated voice to American literary culture. He moved easily between editing, criticism, and politics, leaving behind work that connected books to the larger public conversation.
View all books